少女、側転をして放校に
サンホセ・エジソン・アカデミーのデニス・パットン校長は「何より心配なのは子供たちの安全です。」とし、Faegreちゃんがほかの生徒にぶつかったり、彼女自身がけがをしたり、彼女をまねた生徒がけがをする可能性にふれた。Deirdreちゃんは体操競技を5年間続けている。
Deirdreちゃんの父親リーランドさんはバスケや他のスポーツは許されているのに体操が許されないのはばかばかしいと述べている。(Reuters)【吉】

"We skipped the light fandango, turned cartwheels 'cross the floor..."
![]()
![]()
|
|
|

11-Year-Old Declares Victory In Battle Over Cartwheels

pitch (p
ch)
n. Chiefly British A playing field. Also called
wicket
![]()
Edition 3DCSAT 13 NOV 2004, Page 116
Only in America; Magic sponge
OWEN SLOT
SPORT
---The Times of London Headline Over a Story about the Cartwheel Suspension
|
|
It looks
like the fun Nazis are at it again. According to an article from Reuters,
little Deirdre Faegre has been suspended from her school in Los Angeles
because she was, gasp, doing cartwheels. My god, what is next somersaults or
ever worse the dreaded handstands? The fun Gestapo has gotten out of hand over
the last few years removing the fun activities from the children's playgrounds
and gym classes. School officials and "Safety Polizei" do not want them to
have "winners and losers," they feel that this may scar the little tykes for
life if they are not all labeled winners all of the time. Heaven forbid a
child scrape their knee, bruise themselves, or otherwise come to grief. Where
did all the fun stuff on the playground go, sure there were minor casualties,
but you either got better at it or tried something else. Children of all ages
used to have recess and time to run around and burn up excess energy from
being pent up for seven and a half hours a day just listening and lining up in
hallways (there would have been a whole lot less call for ritalin et al, and a
whole lots less obese children). Lawyers and Government schools have taken all
the fun out of being a child. Principal Denise Patton's "first concern is the
safety of all children." I think it's high time that we go back and find Ms.
Patton's grade school Principal and string her up. Let's find out why she was
so callus in allowing the children of her school to gallivant around the
playground and play on Chinese merry-go-rounds, teeter-totters, jungle gyms
and all of the other recess monstrosities that Ms. Patton had so deftly dodged
as a child. Ms. Patton and her entire graduating class of 11-year olds deserve
medals, the ones that lived unscathed from the maniacal playground menaces,
for what they had to endure. If they only knew, If they only knew.
Jonathan Clausen, 11/15/2004 11:14:49 AM | link | (0) comments |
Sadly, they find fame as victims


Courtesy of http://www.dahog.com
Bursty (Biggest Movers)
Point
|
Compromise best (Your View,
San
Gabriel Valley Tribune, Nov. 21, 2004) I am a sixth-grade student at San Jose Edison Academy in West Covina, and I would like to give my point of view on Deirdre Faegre, (she was in my class last year). I think she should be allowed to do her gymnastics in a designated area. But I also think that she was told many times and gave many warnings to stop, but she kept on going, which was wrong. But I do believe it was wrong if her father told her to go against the schools warnings. Also I think it's wrong if her father is going to home school her because she is going to miss all of her friends. Michael P. Anderson West Covina |
Counterpoint
|
From gymnast's view Re "Cartwheel compromise best,' (Your View, San Gabriel Valley Tribune, Nov. 24, 2004) The reason I refused to stop (doing cartwheels) was because I was not given a designated area even though my parents had asked for it. Also, the school never made it an issue at the beginning of the year. There are many sports out there and you can get hurt by playing all of them, but they did not allow my sport. My dad helped me because there are many people in the past who made great changes such as Luther and Galileo and Rosa Parks that stood up to stubborn unfairness. If you do not go against something that is wrong how do you expect to fix your problems? It is a good thing my dad will home-school me because education these days is not as good as it should be. I will not miss my friends because we have one another's phone numbers and we can see each other any time. Also my dad says that anyone not using the schools should not have to pay for them. Deirdre Faegre West Covina |
I want
to say hello and thank you very much for your support. I am going to
stand up for all kids if I have to stand on my hands to do it. With
your support, we put a stop to these "handstand battalions and cartwheel
cops." And thank you for trusting me because there were quite a
few myths about the last few months. If you would
like to help kids be kids, please write to your local media, my
principal,
and to school board members
Mike Spence
and
Richard Vladlovic.
And cc me at
dfaegre@aol.com.
And don't ever give up! |
---Deirdre
"...It was later discovered that her lunch consisted of six Hostess twinkies and two cans of Red Bull."
---Anonymous

Related Story: Cartwheel Politics
Blue in the face: Angry Democrats can't see they are losing their grip
John Stossel's 'Stupid in America'
![]()
The author of the highly acclaimed
FedEd: The New Federal Curriculum and How It’s Enforced
now takes a closer look at the ideological battle taking place in our schools.
America's Schools: The Battleground for Freedom
By Allen Quist
WITH FRIENDS LIKE THESE, PITY AMERICA'S KIDS
And Please Sign the Separation of School and State Proclamation
![]()
"First, God created idiots. That was just for practice. Then He created school boards."
--- Mark Twain
![]()
| Personally, I still sympathize with the
Faegre family, and
give a tip of the hat to Leland
Faegre for
manipulating both the press and public sympathy into his court. He's got a
political agenda that will get marginally more interest now that his
daughter is semi-famous. The name "Deirdre
Faegre" is
probably among the top 100 search terms on Google this weekend (which
makes her 2,000,000,000,000th overall). ---Chris Elam, Safety for Dummies, 11/15/04 |
![]()

|
"Playground monitor, Edwina Funklebutt has had it
out for
Deirdre Faegre
for years. "There's only gonna be one freaky name on these grounds, dammit!" ---Unnamed Source |
NEWS RELATED :
ARE SCHOOLS GETTING TOO CONTROLLING? CAN KIDS BE KIDS AT SCHOOL?
| Yes |
|
|
| Wish I could do a cartwheel! |
|
|
| No |
|
![]()
"When cartwheels are outlawed, only outlaws will do cartwheels..."
---Anonymous
![]()
The penalties of excellence
And you laugh at the satirical content of the notion...until you read the following from the preferred news publication of peterdavid.net, "The Week": "A California sixth grader was suspended from school for performing cartwheels and handstands in the schoolyard. Eleven-year-old Deirdre Faegre 'created an unsafe situation for herself and others,' said principal Denise Patton. She explained that other, less skilled kids might try to imitate Faegre and get hurt. In that case, Faegre said, the school should also ban basketball." Suddenly it's not as funny anymore. PAD
Original Post by Peter David at
www.peterdavid.net
01:07
PM |
Comments (76) |
TrackBack (0) |
Other blogs commenting
Posted by Oryan at November 27, 2004 09:00 PM This whole thread made my head hurt. This is what happens when you start down a bad road and try to make it better with patchwork solutions. I'm sure this will fan the flames, but....this is why people want school choice. Why the public school system should not have a monopoly on education or, yet, not exist at all. This girl apparently is good at cartwheels. Really good. The principal's problem seems to be that if other students emulate her without the skills, they'll get hurt. The folks in the thread who compare this to the football or basketball teams have it dead on. Why should any student, possessed of skills, be discouraged or punished for displaying them when they don't hurt anybody?? I figured this one out years ago when I was a good student academically, but not athletically. The trophies on display in the halls went to the strong kids, not the smart ones. They got sent home on awards night with a pat on the back and a kick in the ass cause the durable award went to the locker room bully. Our lesson: "yeah, yeah, report cards are just spiffy, but better run that gridiron like a champ." Now, this circumstance shows us the reverse. If this girl had, say a talent for designing guns. I mean of course, on paper, drawing blueprints, that sort of thing. Anybody want to bet she'd still be in a sling with Mr. Principal? What if another child built one of her designs? What if she did? The school can't be endorsing this type of violent creation...heavens, no. In all three examples, as well as some others posted to the thread, creativity, creation and achievement, the things our schools are by their very mission designed to instill, are verboten by an arbitrary standard handed down by the bias of one or a few administrators. Not a fan of handsprings? Call them dangerous and punish them, while endorsing hockey. Don't like hockey, but love the balance beam....by all means scratch the hockey games. This bias can be applied to more cerebral pastimes, of course. The main problem here is while if it was my backyard or yours, or ABC Inc.'s school, we'd simply say "well, they set the rules. Stop the backflips." But, see, this is the State. If we don't like what a private group does, we pack our bags and head for the one we do like, or like better, but not with the state. In this case, public schools. The principal pulls a stunt like telling a student to curb her natural abilities, we get big conflict, like we got. I haven't forgotten about you folks who said "well, the girl wasn't punished for backflips, she was punished cause she wouldn't listen to the teacher." What's next? telling the sighted kids to wear blindfolds because of the visually-impaired student? At a certain point, one fellow was right in the thread, officials lose all their authority when their rules display obvious bias, in this case, literally, a child could spot it. What's that you say? The law does this to all of us at one point or another? We all have to put up with nonsensical rules, like the girl should have, or we go to the slammer? True, but as one can see, our prison population us way way up, and our society is increasingly polarized on this issue of when its a good idea to ban behaviors which affect little outside of ourselves, and which in turn, frequently cause ourselves to learn the best new ways to do things. In short, there's no moral high ground to stand on with the story of the girl's suspension. Students should listen to teachers, and teachers should not be so shortsighted as to stifle student talents. Barring a utopia, it'd be nice if this girl could easily have said "Mr. Principal, if you don't like me using my natural ability to do handsprings in school, that's okay, my parents and I will start transferring me to a new school tonight, but Mr. Principal, if you do this to too many students who utilize their talents in ways you don't like, you may need to find yourself a new job. Kevin Ryan |

|
SJEA Education: now there is an oxymoron...
Dear Board President Spence
|
![]()
|
|||||
![]()
|
Hi Deirdre~ My name is Jennifer Parkes, and I have to say I agree with your father that suspending you from school for doing cartwheels and handstands is unreal. My daughter is also a competitive gymnast and has been corrected at school dances for doing basic gymnastics stunts and even in school for the same things. Fortunately she has never been suspended, but it just so crazy. They are allowed to play basketball at dances and "slam dance" but let someone stand on their hands and oohhh that's so scary it must be dangerous. I just wanted to say that while I'm the whole way across the country my daughter and I both feel for you and just wanted to say we are sorry. It would be so nice if people would take the time to understand gymnastics and while yes it can be dangerous it is no more dangerous than football, wrestling and other sports and they are allowed to be done on school property during school time. Keep your chin up!! Jennifer |

| On Behalf of Deirdre Leland Faegre http://www.ontopofacloud.com Tell Deirdre to keep fighting. My daughter |

She said, "There is no reason and the truth is plain to see."
| Principal SJEA YEP, YOUR SCHOOL IS DISTINGUISHED, ALRIGHT. But sadly, for its absurd and draconian leadership. Suspension, gymnastics, infamy. Education at San Jose-Edison Academy. Now there's an oxymoron. Felice Data Marin County, CA |


The Cartwheel Chronicles
| Thu - November 11, 2004 | ||||||
|
Reference:
Student suspended for handstands, cartwheels
I don't know what to say about this. I couldn't even think of a good title for this entry. So, I'm going to just reprint the whole article here. Hopefully the follow-up on this story will be headlined "Principal Fired for incompetence, idiocy."
|
|
An 11-year old girl in California was
suspended from school for performing cartwheels and handstands during
lunchtime.
Now, it seems a common defense to argue that “individual liberties” are at risk as schoolhouse nannies strive to produce a world of the lowest common denominator, where excellence is forbidden because others might somehow feel bad (Harry Harrison, they thought your short story was a laudable goal!). I’m not automatically on the girl’s side here: my first thought was that she was performing say, in the school cafeteria. If she were, certainly it would make sense for school officials to tell her to stop. But it sounds like she was at recess and on the playground. And it certainly sounds like the nannies were out in force - after all, “other children could get hurt trying to imitate Deirdre.” They’ve already banned dodgeball and want to outlaw most contact sports - too dangerous, not everybody can be “good” at them, etc. Meanwhile, obesity among school children is a significant problem. I’m thinking school officials are again up to their standard busy-body tricks: the self-esteem Nazis covering their tracks with purported worries about “injuries.”
|

There's only one possible response to this, and
Kimberly
Swygert, no slouch herself at doing the 'wheel, has already made it:
The kind of place, in other words, where even superheroes could be sued for saving lives. Rock on, Dr. Swygert. And Deirdre — when you make the Olympic team come 2012 (2008?), make sure you forget to mention where you went to school. They don't deserve you. Posted at 7:22 PM to
Dyssynergy
|

2004.11.12少女、側転をして放校に
禁止されていた逆立ちや側転を昼休みにくりかえしていたとして、ロスアンゼルスに住むDeirdre
Faegreちゃん(11)が小学校から一時放校となった、
サンホセ・エジソン・アカデミーのデニス・パットン校長は「何より心配なのは子供たちの安全です。」とし、Faegreちゃんがほかの生徒にぶつかったり、彼女自身がけがをしたり、彼女をまねた生徒がけがをする可能性にふれた。Deirdreちゃんは体操競技を5年間続けている。 Deirdreちゃんの父親リーランドさんはバスケや他のスポーツは許されているのに体操が許されないのはばかばかしいと述べている。(Reuters)【吉】
|
International Media Coverage:
INTERNATIONAL SOCIETY FOR INDIVIDUAL LIBERTY
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Member, USA Gymnastics
|
||||
|
And now, a description of rape in her required reading... |
|
---Denise Patton, Principal, San Jose Edison Academy
|
The Newest, Newbery Assault on the Innocence of Children
EducationNews.org
The Internet’s Leading Source of
EducationNews
Daily News
Bulletin Board
Free On-Line
Subscription
Home
Contact Us
-- recognized as a quality online resource for
education reporters --
November 2002,
Education Writers Association (over 900
members)
First Amendment no big deal, students say
![]()
Study shows American teenagers indifferent to freedoms
Don't Let Congress Fund Orwellian Psychiatric Screening of Kids
January 31, 2005
Parental
Consent Act -- H.R. 181
(Mental Screening of Children)
'No Child Left Behind' Blamed for Cancellation of Spelling Bee
"Is it any wonder that children aren't performing up to par when their administrators are clueless!"
---Friends of Dave, 1/31/05
|
October 20, 1993 |
|
|
|
|
|||
|
|
|
Top Ten Reasons Dan
Quayle Would Make A Good President 10. Picked up a lot of jargon from Bush, like "congress" and "Washington" 9. Would be fun to see it spelled "Natoe" 8. Five words: State of the Union flashcards 7. No need for Camp David; give him a box of styrofoam peanuts and he's entertained for hours 6. New cabinet post: Secretary of cartoons 5. Was allowed to visit the White House once during the Bush administration 4. Wouldn't be out of touch with the concerns of the not-so-bright 3. America is the Love Boat, and he wants to be our Captain Stubing (shot of Gavin Macleod) 2. His wife is smart enough to run the country 1. Four more years of Quayle jokes 10/20/93 |
|

Singer/Songwriter
Member, American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers
Listen To My Debut Single, 'Shining in My Hair' ASCAP
Released 6/4/2006
|
Images from the Vocal and Acoustic Guitar Session |
|
'Down to Hear Studios,' 5/13/2006 |
It's Here, My Follow-Up Single,
|
Release Date: 6/3/2007 |
Images from the Vocal and Acoustic Guitar Sessions, Cloverland Studios
|
Words and Music by |
|
|
|
Piano and Vocals by Deirdre Leah Faegre; Arranged by Deirdre Leah Faegre |
|
Arranged and Produced by Leland Thomas Faegre |
|
All Guitars and Percussion by Leland Thomas Faegre |
|
Engineered by Leland Thomas Faegre at On Top Of a Cloud; Additional Engineering by Billy Sullivan at Cloverland Studios; Engineered and Mastered by David Scharf at |
Den wrote...
I've always been a firm believer that whenever an authority figure is an idiot, they forfeit all of their authority.
If that isn't inviting this to become another political thread, I don't know what is =)
It's interesting that the one article mentions another side of the story, but I can't figure out what that could be. Of course, the school would have the right to ask the girl to stop if her actions were overly dangerous, as has been mentioned, but I'm not sure "cartwheels and handstands" qualify.